Bitcoin and the American Dream traces how four presidential administrations, Congress, regulators, and Wall Street shaped Bitcoin’s journey from an obscure experiment to a consequential American financial asset. In this ten-part series, we examine what each administration got right, what it got wrong, and whether America protected the freedom to build.
America was watching its financial system come apart in the autumn of 2008. Lehman Brothers had collapsed, Washington was rescuing financial institutions, and millions of families were discovering that the people entrusted with protecting their savings had taken risks ordinary Americans never understood. Homes were lost, retirement accounts were devastated, and taxpayers were asked to help stabilize institutions whose mistakes they had not made. The American Dream had encountered a painful contradiction. The people who worked, saved, and played by the rules were paying for the failures of people who had not.
Six weeks after Lehman’s bankruptcy, an unknown individual or group using the name Satoshi Nakamoto published Bitcoin: A Peer-to-Peer Electronic Cash System. On January 3, 2009, while George W. Bush was still president, Bitcoin’s first block was mined. Embedded inside was a newspaper headline about another British bank bailout. The message was difficult to miss, although Satoshi never supplied a complete political manifesto explaining it. Bitcoin offered something extraordinary: a monetary system whose issuance schedule could not be rewritten by a central banker, politician, or corporate board.
When Barack Obama entered the White House seventeen days later, Bitcoin was barely known outside cryptography circles. Washington had larger emergencies, and nobody was predicting that a collection of computers running unfamiliar software would eventually command the attention of presidents, Congress, and Wall Street. Yet the underlying question was already profoundly American. Could ordinary people voluntarily exchange and preserve value without requiring permission from a financial institution? That question belonged in a country founded upon individual liberty, private property, and the freedom to pursue opportunity.
The Obama administration did not ban Bitcoin. That matters because history should not be rewritten to satisfy political preferences. Instead, federal agencies began applying existing laws to an unfamiliar technology. In March 2013, Treasury’s Financial Crimes Enforcement Network established that businesses exchanging or administering convertible virtual currency could face money-transmission obligations, while ordinary users were treated differently. In March 2014, the IRS classified virtual currency as property for federal tax purposes. In September 2015, the Commodity Futures Trading Commission asserted its authority over virtual currencies as commodities.
Those decisions gave Bitcoin a place within American law, but they also created complications that remain with us. Bitcoin could be treated as property when taxed, a commodity when traded, and something resembling money when transmitted through a business. Each agency viewed the same technology through its existing jurisdiction. Congress had not designed a comprehensive framework, leaving entrepreneurs to navigate overlapping rules. Government had recognized Bitcoin without fully understanding what Americans might build with it.
New York demonstrated the danger of excessive regulation in 2015. Its BitLicense requirements caused several digital-asset businesses to stop serving residents rather than shoulder the compliance burden. This was a state decision, not an Obama executive order, but it revealed a problem that would become increasingly familiar. Large companies can hire lawyers, compliance departments, and consultants. Small innovators often cannot. When government makes the entrance fee too expensive, capitalism does not disappear. Opportunity simply moves somewhere else.
The Justice Department also pursued criminal activity involving Bitcoin, including the Silk Road marketplace. Stopping illegal commerce was a legitimate government responsibility. The more revealing financial decision came afterward, when the U.S. Marshals Service began auctioning forfeited bitcoin. In June 2014, approximately 29,656 BTC were sold, with investor Tim Draper winning the auction. Additional sales followed. Bitcoin that might eventually have formed part of a national reserve was converted into dollars long before Washington began discussing strategic ownership.
Consider that first auction alone. At an illustrative Bitcoin price of $65,000, those 29,656 coins would be worth approximately $1.93 billion. The auction generated roughly $19 million at the time. That is an extraordinary difference, although hindsight is not a financial strategy and forfeiture law, victims’ rights, and legal obligations cannot simply be ignored. Still, Americans deserve to ask whether government should have developed a lawful framework for retaining some forfeited Bitcoin rather than routinely selling it. The opportunity cost belongs in our national accounting.
George Washington understood that public stewardship extends beyond the next election. Alexander Hamilton understood that national credit depends upon disciplined financial management. Neither man knew Bitcoin, and neither should be recruited into arguments he never made. But both recognized that a republic must think beyond immediate convenience. A government responsible for future generations should examine valuable public assets with the same seriousness expected of a prudent household.
Scripture offers an important distinction. In Matthew 25, Jesus tells the parable of servants entrusted with their master’s resources. The lesson is not that every asset will appreciate or that Bitcoin is divinely favored. It concerns faithfulness, responsibility, and accountability for what has been entrusted. God calls us to exercise judgment rather than bury responsibility beneath fear or surrender it to convenience. That principle applies to households, businesses, and public officials alike.
I believe capitalism remains one of America’s greatest instruments for turning human creativity into opportunity. It rewards people willing to build, serve customers, invest capital, and accept responsibility for failure. Government should punish theft and fraud, enforce honest contracts, and protect property rights. It should not require entrepreneurs to obtain permission from an expanding bureaucracy simply to discover whether their ideas can work. Freedom to build is part of the American Dream, and regulation must protect that freedom rather than quietly consume it.
The Obama years established Bitcoin’s first American legal foundation. Some decisions provided necessary clarity. Others imposed burdens or surrendered opportunities that deserve serious examination. That is neither a Republican nor Democratic conclusion. It is a judgment about stewardship. Bitcoin survived because its rules did not depend upon Washington’s approval, and American entrepreneurs continued building because they believed something valuable could emerge from the wreckage of a broken financial system.
Kingdom Principle 👑
A nation honors stewardship when it protects honest enterprise, restrains wrongdoing, and manages public resources with tomorrow’s generations in mind.
The American Dream was never a promise that every investment would succeed. It was a promise of opportunity within a nation where people could work, build, own property, and pursue a better future without unnecessary interference. Government has a legitimate responsibility to protect that opportunity, but it must remember that opportunity does not originate in Washington.
The parable of the talents reminds us that resources carry responsibility. We cannot judge every past decision using knowledge available only today, but we can learn from those decisions and demand greater wisdom tomorrow. God entrusts us with time, abilities, property, and opportunities. The Holy Spirit forms the discernment and character required to steward them faithfully.
Bitcoin is not our salvation. It is a tool that challenges us to think more seriously about money, authority, ownership, and the future we are preparing for our children. The measure of our faithfulness is not whether we recognized every opportunity perfectly. It is whether we are willing to pursue truth, learn from mistakes, and protect what has been entrusted to us.
Prayer 🙏
Heavenly Father, thank You for the ingenuity, courage, and perseverance You place within people who build. Thank You for the freedoms that have allowed generations of Americans to create businesses, pursue opportunity, and provide for their families. Give our nation leaders who understand that public office is a responsibility to serve rather than a license to control.
Lord Jesus, teach us to distinguish honest enterprise from exploitation and necessary regulation from unnecessary interference. Give us the courage to confront wrongdoing without condemning innovation itself. Help us learn from decisions that surrendered long-term opportunities, while remaining fair to those who acted with the information and legal responsibilities available to them.
Holy Spirit, form wisdom in our households, integrity in our businesses, and humility in our government. May America remain a place where builders can build, families can flourish, and the next generation inherits greater opportunity rather than greater dependence. Keep our confidence rooted in God, our judgments grounded in truth, and our technology beneath faithful stewardship.
May the rebuilding of honest money begin with the rebuilding of honest responsibility. In Jesus’ name, Amen. 🙏📖🇺🇸🏛️⚖️🛠️🏠₿🕊️👑


