Bitcoin and the American Dream traces how four presidential administrations, Congress, regulators, and Wall Street shaped Bitcoin’s journey from an obscure experiment to a consequential American financial asset. In this ten-part series, we examine what each administration got right, what it got wrong, and whether America protected the freedom to build.
In December 2017, something remarkable happened in American financial markets. Bitcoin futures began trading on regulated exchanges, first at CBOE and then at the Chicago Mercantile Exchange. An asset once dismissed as internet play money had entered institutions whose business was managing financial risk. The doors were opening, although Washington seemed uncertain whether to welcome the new arrival or ask security to escort it outside. That contradiction would define Donald Trump’s first presidency.
Trump entered office in January 2017 with Bitcoin trading near $1,000. His administration inherited an emerging industry, overlapping regulatory jurisdictions, and entrepreneurs eager to build in America. By the time he departed in January 2021, Bitcoin was approaching $35,000. That extraordinary appreciation was not evidence that the president had championed it. In fact, Trump publicly declared in July 2019 that he was “not a fan of Bitcoin,” describing its value as based on thin air.
I appreciate President Trump’s willingness to challenge conventional thinking, but that particular judgment missed something important. Bitcoin’s value was not created by a government decree or guaranteed by a corporation. It emerged from voluntary participation, mathematical scarcity, and a network whose rules participants could independently verify. Markets determine whether those characteristics deserve value. A conservative defense of capitalism should begin by allowing free people to make that judgment.
Fortunately, presidential skepticism did not prevent important institutional progress. Under CFTC Chairman J. Christopher Giancarlo (aka Crypto Dad), regulated Bitcoin futures launched in December 2017. Futures allowed investors and businesses to manage exposure through established clearing and trading infrastructure. The Commodity Futures Trading Commission had already recognized virtual currencies as commodities during the Obama years, but the Trump-era launches gave that classification practical financial significance. Wall Street was beginning to construct bridges to an asset it had spent years questioning.
The Securities and Exchange Commission took a more restrictive approach. Under Chairman Jay Clayton, the agency rejected or delayed proposals for spot Bitcoin exchange-traded products, citing concerns about manipulation and surveillance of underlying markets. Those concerns deserved examination, especially in an industry experiencing fraud and speculation. But repeatedly withholding access also meant American investors lacked a familiar regulated product while other investment structures developed. Protecting investors should not automatically mean denying them choices.
The SEC’s July 2017 DAO Report established another consequential principle. Certain digital tokens sold to raise capital could qualify as securities under existing law. That was not a declaration that Bitcoin itself was a security, and the distinction matters. Fraudulent offerings deserve prosecution, but legitimate entrepreneurs also deserve to know which rules apply before investing their savings in a business. Capitalism cannot flourish when compliance becomes a guessing game.
Then came a genuine breakthrough. In July 2020, the Office of the Comptroller of the Currency, led by Acting Comptroller Brian Brooks, clarified that national banks could provide cryptocurrency custody services. This recognized that protecting digital property could become a legitimate banking activity. It did not force banks to participate or eliminate their supervisory obligations. It opened a door through which American financial institutions could compete.
American entrepreneurs were already demonstrating what that opportunity looked like. In August 2020, Michael Saylor’s MicroStrategy purchased 21,454 bitcoin for approximately $250 million, beginning a corporate treasury strategy that would influence businesses worldwide. PayPal introduced cryptocurrency buying and selling for eligible American customers later that year. These were private enterprises risking capital and building services, not government programs distributing taxpayer subsidies. They were examples of the American Dream functioning as intended.
Yet the administration ended with a troubling contradiction. In December 2020, Treasury’s FinCEN proposed additional reporting and identification requirements involving transactions with self-hosted wallets. The proposal was not a ban on self-custody, but it raised serious concerns about privacy, compliance burdens, and the government’s expanding reach into lawful financial activity. Its unusually short initial comment period compounded those concerns. This restriction came from a Republican administration, and conservatives should be willing to say so.
The American founders understood why that distinction matters. James Madison designed constitutional checks around the reality that government power, however well intentioned, requires limits. Theodore Roosevelt later demonstrated that strong enforcement against genuine abuses could coexist with vigorous American enterprise. Neither limited government nor capitalism requires tolerating fraud. They require laws that punish wrongdoing without making honest innovation unnecessarily difficult.
Scripture gives us an even older principle. Proverbs 11:1 teaches that dishonest scales are detestable to God, but accurate weights find His favor. The passage concerns honesty in commerce, not a prediction about Bitcoin or a command to deregulate financial markets. Its moral standard applies equally to businesses that deceive customers and regulators who exercise authority without fairness. Truth must govern both sides of the transaction.
The Trump administration’s first term therefore deserves a balanced judgment. Regulated futures, bank-custody guidance, and expanding private enterprise helped establish foundations for future adoption. ETF resistance, uncertainty around digital securities, presidential skepticism, and the proposed wallet-reporting rule created barriers. The record is neither uniformly positive nor uniformly negative, and pretending otherwise would weaken the argument for freedom.
I remain convinced that America’s greatest competitive advantage is not Washington’s ability to select winners. It is the freedom of entrepreneurs to discover possibilities that government never imagined. Ronald Reagan understood that prosperity grows when government trusts citizens to create, compete, and build. Our responsibility is to defend that freedom consistently, even when the politician imposing the restriction happens to belong to our preferred party.
By January 2021, Bitcoin had survived another cycle, Wall Street had established its first regulated trading bridges, and American businesses were building an increasingly serious industry. The next administration would inherit those foundations and make decisions with profound consequences for the people building upon them. The question was whether Washington would clarify the rules or make regulatory uncertainty itself the price of doing business in America.
Kingdom Principle 👑
Free enterprise flourishes when government protects honest commerce, punishes genuine wrongdoing, and respects the responsibility God has entrusted to individuals and families.
Capitalism is not a license to deceive, exploit, or escape accountability. It is an economic system that allows people to use their abilities, property, initiative, and capital to serve others through voluntary exchange. Proper regulation protects that exchange from fraud and coercion. Excessive regulation can destroy the opportunity before a legitimate business ever reaches its first customer.
The Trump administration’s first term demonstrated both possibilities. Government helped create pathways for regulated financial participation while other decisions threatened to restrict lawful ownership and innovation. Faithful citizenship requires us to recognize both. Our principles should not change when the occupant of the White House does.
Jesus teaches in Luke 16:10 that faithfulness in small matters reveals something about faithfulness in larger ones. That principle challenges entrepreneurs to honor their customers and public officials to exercise their authority with integrity. The Holy Spirit develops the character necessary for both. America remains strongest when freedom is joined to responsibility and prosperity is pursued without surrendering truth.
Prayer 🙏
Heavenly Father, thank You for the extraordinary freedom Americans have inherited and for the entrepreneurs, engineers, investors, and business leaders willing to take risks and build something useful. Give our nation the wisdom to protect that inheritance. Help us recognize that innovation is often born in places government never expected and through people whose vision others initially dismissed.
Lord Jesus, teach our leaders to distinguish honest enterprise from deception and necessary oversight from unnecessary control. Give regulators courage to confront fraud and humility to recognize the limits of their authority. Protect us from defending poor decisions simply because they came from a political leader we admire, and help us apply the same standard of truth to every administration.
Holy Spirit, strengthen the character of American builders and the discernment of American households. Help us pursue opportunity without greed, exercise freedom without irresponsibility, and protect private property without forgetting our obligations to others. May America remain a nation where people are free to work, create, compete, save, and leave something meaningful to the generations that follow.
May our laws defend honest enterprise, our leaders respect their limits, and our families remain faithful stewards of the freedom entrusted to us. In Jesus’ name, Amen. 🙏📖🇺🇸🏛️⚖️🛠️📈🏠₿🕊️👑


